By using this website, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

Our latest stories, delivered to you inbox.

Don’t worry, we won’t bombard you. Get highlights of the newest stories delivered to your email inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Research disproves
historic medical gaslighting
 

Research disproves historic medical gaslighting

4 min Read | by Jill Moorhead

How patients are finding relief from adrenal fatigue through naturopathic treatment.

Adrenal fatigue has gone by many names—hysteria, neurasthenia, and yuppie flu. Researchers at Harvard refer to it as toxic stress. Dr. Andrew Neville, a naturopathic doctor devoted to treating this condition, says adrenal fatigue’s most accurate name is “stress response system dysfunction.”

The theory behind adrenal fatigue is that chronic stress leaves the adrenal glands exhausted from pumping out cortisol. Eventually, the adrenal glands are unable to keep up with demand, which leaves the body depleted of this hormone that normally plays an important role in controlling metabolism, suppressing inflammation, regulating blood pressure and blood sugars, and regulating the stress response.

Dr. Neville describes “stress response system dysfunction” as a combination of factors that include adrenal dysfunction (which could look like high levels of cortisol, low levels of cortisol, or levels that fluctuate high and low throughout the day), as well as a dysfunction of the nerves (the autonomic nervous system that controls our organs) and the brain (the limbic system that in part controls emotional responses).

Patients with adrenal fatigue describe symptoms as debilitating. It’s like they are constantly stuck in fight-or-flight mode. This state can induce panic attacks, cause people to stop eating, keep them in a brain fog, and leave them feeling drained by simple tasks, like folding laundry.

Tom Cammack, a patient of Dr Neville, says with adrenal fatigue, he lost his appetite and had a hard time digesting food. He spoke to his primary care physician about the symptoms but was wary of the traditional pharmaceuticals prescribed to him like antidepressants and anti-anxiety meds because he wanted to address the underlying cause. “It’s bigger than the symptoms,” says Cammack. “There’s a lot of stress in the world. My mind is fighting against being tricked by it.”

While these symptoms feel real to patients, much
of the medical field believes adrenal fatigue is a
myth. A systematic review of 58 peer reviewed
studies by the National Institutes of Health says
that adrenal fatigue does not exist.
While these symptoms feel
real to patients, much of
the medical field believes
adrenal fatigue is a myth.
A systematic review of 58 peer
reviewed studies by the
National Institutes of Health
says that adrenal fatigue
does not exist.
Two people holding hands,  walking along a sidewalk.

While these symptoms feel real to patients, much of the medical field believes adrenal fatigue is a myth. A systematic review of 58 peer reviewed studies by the National Institutes of Health says that adrenal fatigue does not exist, and the Endocrine Society asserts that adrenal fatigue is not a real disease, claiming there is no hard evidence for its existence.

Neville believes otherwise, and not just because he treats patients with the condition. He came across the term adrenal fatigue when he was looking for answers to his own symptoms. “I had adrenal fatigue way back, and I didn't know what to do about it,” says the Director of the Clymer Healing Center in Quakertown, Pennsylvania. “Conventional medicine didn't have any answers for me.”

The closest Neville could get to studying his own symptoms was specializing in chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia at Bastyr University’s School of Naturopathic Medicine. And for the past 20 years, his practice has focused on better understanding adrenal fatigue and treating patients eager for relief.

Neville says the research exists to make adrenal fatigue an official medical diagnosis, but it is not widely distributed. “It’s in the hands of PhDs or journals; it’s in the stress research. But if doctors don’t look for it, they’re not going to find it.”

The medical controversy around adrenal fatigue creates a hardship for patients because they have a difficult time finding care. And when they do, they’re typically told by the medical establishment that what they’re dealing with is all in their head.

“It’s one of our biggest challenges,” says Neville. “The medical community is taught that if you don’t have Addison’s disease—or complete adrenal failure—then you don’t have an adrenal problem.” He argues that this approach is not consistent with other diagnoses. For example, patients don’t need a complete failure of the thyroid to have a thyroid problem. The same goes for ovarian hormones, he says. Unfortunately, once Addison’s disease is ruled out, traditional practitioners stop considering adrenal glands as part of the problem.

Lisa Lindblom, a retired special education teacher from Westchester County, New York, said her adrenal fatigue symptoms were so intense that she would lay in bed at night exhausted and astonished, thinking to herself, “Wow, I made it through another day alive.”

Advertisment:
“Medical Gaslighting?”
The medical controversy around adrenal fatigue
creates a hardship for patients because they have
a difficult time finding care. And when they do,
they’re typically told by the medical
establishment that what they’re dealing with is
all in their head.
“Medical Gaslighting?”
The medical controversy
around adrenal fatigue
creates a hardship for
patients because they have
a difficult time finding care.
And when they do, they’re
typically told by the medical
establishment that what
they’re dealing with is
all in their head.

She experienced frequent chest pain, and lost 11 pounds in a month. She went to the hospital weekly but was told nothing was wrong with her. Although she had a history of stable mental health, she became suicidal. “I’m not crazy, but everyone was telling me that I was absolutely fine. I was super upset and insulted when that would happen,” Lindblom remembers. “There are probably a lot of people out there with this, to a lesser or greater extent. And it goes undiagnosed.”

A woman smiling, looking at someone off-camera.

Working with Neville, she calmed her system, and the changes became apparent to her primary care physician. “My doctor now sees that my blood pressure is stable, and he sees how good I look,” she says. Her doctor has expressed interest in speaking to Neville. “He told me that he cannot deny the fact that I am a thousand percent better.”

Neville says more of the medical field are acknowledging that adrenal fatigue is real, and social media has helped to bring about this awareness. Functional medicine practitioners are now listing adrenal fatigue on their websites, and Neville is adding to the literature by writing his own book on adrenal fatigue and its complexities.

“It’s good that more people are aware,” says Neville, “but when doctors find this adrenal fatigue thing, they just kind of grabbed the hold of the tail of something that's way bigger than they anticipated. We have to make almost heroic efforts to turn on the opposite physiology. But when you can do it, you’ve literally saved somebody’s life. It’s pretty powerful,” he pauses, “I’m blessed to be able to do what I do.”

Show your support
Advertisment:
P. S.

The artwork in the article is made from scans of an art therapy collage that I created to reflect on a stressful period of my life in which I struggled with a panic disorder that led to a lot of the symptoms described as ‘adrenal fatigue’. I hope that this article will provide the same validation to others, as it did for me.

Allie Stokey, Designer
Scans from art therapy collage.

Explore more

about us

We are curious, driven healthcare journalists and artists.

About us

share your story

Your story may make all the difference in someone else’s life. Let them hear it.

Contribute

Support our work

Help us tell more stories, reach more people, change more lives.

donate